Alright let's get some LSD on this topic:

The banner is quite plain/proffesional.
N/U is a FPS Gaming Community.

Plain/Proffesional does not = FPS Gaming Community.
If a new player visits the website they're gonna see clean, plain, blatant layouts. They might be all like "Wtf? Is this cookiecentral.com?" (Idk if it's a website so dont try it) then peace out.

What it needs (Much like noogy said) FPS reference, someone gettin shot the Eff up, or an explosion or something of the sort.

Druggy out.